Assuming good faith members then yes, but some people don't act in good faith. What some call the "I'm not born yesterday-rule" or "don't make me make a new rule-rule", if there's clear intent to cause problems then you can nuke the account even if there was no prior rule. You can't predict all harm
I feel like this works at smaller scale where the person making the call is plugged in with all relevant context... but at platform scale your mods need to be working on a consistent set of policies so it doesn't depend on the mood of the person making the call
More notes on nearby ideas
Reply · Jul 16, 2023imo the way that should work is to adopt the new policy, remove the violation content, and then going forward have bans as a consequence for posting…Reply · Nov 28, 2023@fuzzyunclear huh strange! the mod policies are way overzealous imo!!!Reply · Dec 12, 2023@NoncanonicAleae 😏 i feel like u may have interesting experiences by violating these rules occasionally... but in general yeahReply · May 27, 2023imo the question is how should platform / mods handle something like this... one side wants alice banned from bsky entirely, the current result is the…